If Bolivia Could Buy Back Its Debt at 11 Cents on the Dollar in 1988, Why Are We Still Asking the Same Questions Today?

Published on 16 November 2026 at 20:01

Nearly four decades ago, Bolivia demonstrated that a debt worth hundreds of millions on paper could be settled for a fraction of its face value. Today, Michael Sheen is cancelling people's debts, Wall Street continues trading distressed loans, and ordinary borrowers are still struggling to understand a financial system in which the value of their obligations can change dramatically depending on who owns them. Perhaps it is time we stopped treating debt as an unquestionable moral obligation and started examining it as the financial commodity it has become.

A remarkable transaction that history almost forgot

In March 1988, Bolivia accomplished something that should still make us question the foundations of the modern debt industry. The impoverished South American country used approximately $34 million in funds donated by foreign governments to repurchase and retire $308 million of its outstanding commercial bank debt. That represented roughly 46 percent of the country's foreign commercial bank debt, purchased at just 11 cents on the dollar.

Think about that for a moment. A financial obligation recorded at $308 million could effectively disappear for $34 million. The remaining $274 million in nominal claims was extinguished, not because Bolivia had suddenly become wealthy, but because the banks holding those claims were willing to accept a price reflecting how little they expected to recover.

This was not some obscure financial rumour. The transaction became the subject of serious economic debate, including research published by the Brookings Institution in 1988. Economists Jeremy Bulow and Kenneth Rogoff questioned whether the operation delivered as much benefit to Bolivia as its headline figures suggested. Jeffrey Sachs offered a different interpretation of the potential advantages of comprehensive debt reduction.

There was a particularly revealing complication. As Bolivia's debt was retired, the market price of its remaining obligations increased. Creditors who continued holding Bolivian debt could therefore benefit from the transaction, even though the country had reduced its outstanding liabilities. The apparent savings were not necessarily equivalent to the country's real economic gains.

That distinction matters. Bolivia's debt relief was financed by international donors, involved sovereign obligations rather than personal loans, and produced outcomes that economists continue to interpret differently.

But none of those complications eliminates the central observation.

The banks recognised that the face value of a debt was not necessarily its economic value. They negotiated accordingly.

And that raises a question which has troubled me increasingly as I have examined the modern debt industry: if financial institutions can negotiate debts according to what they are realistically worth, why are ordinary people so often expected to treat the original amount as something almost sacred?

When a debt becomes a commodity, the rules change

Most people understand borrowing through a relatively simple relationship. You receive money, agree to repay it under certain conditions, and accept responsibility for meeting those obligations. That principle is not unreasonable. Without enforceable agreements, lending would become more expensive, more uncertain and, for many people, considerably harder to obtain.

The problem becomes more complicated when the original relationship breaks down.

A person loses a job, becomes ill, experiences a divorce or encounters financial difficulties that were impossible to predict when the loan was signed. Payments stop. The creditor may eventually decide that recovering the full outstanding amount is unlikely or no longer economically worthwhile.

The debt may then be sold.

In secondary debt markets, portfolios of distressed or non-performing loans can change ownership at substantial discounts. The buyer is not necessarily paying anything close to the nominal amount owed. Instead, the price reflects expected recoveries, collection expenses, legal risks, time and the probability that some borrowers will never pay.

A debt of $10,000 might be sold for a fraction of that amount, depending on the portfolio and its characteristics. The purchaser nevertheless generally acquires the enforceable contractual claim, subject to applicable law, rather than a claim automatically reduced to the purchase price.

There is nothing inherently mysterious about selling financial assets below their face value. A company can sell distressed inventory at a discount. An investor can sell shares at a loss. A bank can dispose of problematic loans to reduce uncertainty and free up resources.

Yet debt introduces a peculiar human dimension.

The original lender may consider the debt worth very little. The new purchaser may have paid a small proportion of the amount outstanding. But the person whose name appears on the account can still face demands based on the full legally recoverable balance, potentially including permitted interest and fees.

One person's financial failure becomes another person's investment opportunity.

Of course, buying distressed debt is not automatically exploitative. Collection costs can be substantial, many debts are never recovered, and a portfolio containing thousands of accounts cannot be valued by looking at one successful collection. Legitimate debt purchasers also operate within legal restrictions that differ considerably between countries.

Still, the fundamental asymmetry deserves attention. Professional creditors participate in a sophisticated market where obligations are valued according to probabilities and negotiated prices. Individual debtors often encounter the same obligations as fixed amounts accompanied by legal warnings and deadlines.

The market sees an asset with an uncertain recovery value.

The individual sees a bill that could destroy their financial future.

Both are looking at the same debt.

From Bolivia to Michael Sheen: the uncomfortable mathematics of forgiveness

In March 2025, Welsh actor Michael Sheen demonstrated another aspect of this system. Through a project documented in Channel 4's Michael Sheen's Secret Million Pound Giveaway, he spent approximately £100,000 of his own money acquiring around £1 million in personal debt owed by approximately 900 people in South Wales.

He then cancelled it.

The project required establishing a debt acquisition company and navigating a financial industry that was not designed to make charitable debt cancellation particularly straightforward. Sheen did not simply hand money to the borrowers. He entered the market in which their debts were being traded.

The mathematics were strikingly similar to Bolivia's transaction, even though the legal and economic circumstances were entirely different.

In one case, a country retired hundreds of millions of dollars in external commercial bank debt at approximately 11 percent of nominal value. In the other, an actor purchased distressed personal debt at roughly 10 percent of its stated value and extinguished it.

Neither example proves that every debt can be settled at those prices. They were specific transactions involving distressed obligations, with very different structures and financing.

But together they expose something that most people rarely consider.

Debt is not always the immutable financial object we imagine it to be. Its value depends on circumstances, risk, ownership and expectations. Creditors regularly recognise this when making commercial decisions.

The debtor, however, does not necessarily have access to the same information, negotiating position or opportunities.

Sheen's initiative was important not simply because hundreds of people received relief. It demonstrated that a financial mechanism normally used for investment and collection could also be used to remove obligations entirely.

The same underlying market could serve radically different purposes depending on who participated and what they intended to accomplish.

That is a far more interesting observation than whether one wealthy actor deserves applause for an act of generosity.

It suggests that debt relief does not always require inventing an entirely new financial mechanism. Sometimes it requires reconsidering who is allowed to use mechanisms that already exist.

The next revolution may not come from politicians or bankers

Over the past few days, I have been thinking about these stories alongside Bloomberg's investigation into so-called zombie mortgages: old housing debts that can resurface years later, exposing homeowners to collection actions and potentially even foreclosure.

The details of these cases are legally complex, and borrowers' rights depend on the jurisdiction, the documents, the history of payments and other circumstances. Not every revived claim is invalid. But the broader problem is familiar: individuals confronting professional financial organisations armed with legal expertise, historical records and specialised systems for evaluating claims.

A borrower receiving a demand involving a decades-old mortgage may not even know which questions to ask.

Who currently owns the debt? Can the claimant prove the complete chain of ownership? What payments were previously made? Were earlier settlements properly recorded? Does the applicable limitation period affect enforcement? Has the account been calculated correctly?

These are not minor technicalities. They can determine whether a claim is enforceable and what a borrower actually owes.

And this is where I believe an entirely different conversation should begin.

For most of modern financial history, the tools required to investigate complicated financial claims have belonged primarily to institutions. Banks employ specialists, maintain databases, purchase information services and use software to calculate risks and recoveries. Ordinary individuals have traditionally depended on professional assistance, their own limited knowledge or whatever information a creditor provides.

Artificial intelligence is beginning to change what individuals can do for themselves.

Not because an AI system can magically eliminate debt. It cannot. Nor should anyone trust an unverified chatbot to interpret financial contracts, calculate legally enforceable balances or provide definitive legal advice.

But carefully designed digital tools can help people organise documents, identify missing information, understand financial terminology, calculate possible repayment scenarios and prepare more informed questions for qualified advisers.

They can make complex information understandable.

They can help a person discover that a claimed balance needs clarification before accepting it unquestioningly.

They can make it easier to approach an adviser with an organised account of the situation instead of a plastic bag filled with unopened letters.

Perhaps most importantly, they can restore some ability to act to people who have gradually lost confidence in their own capacity to deal with financial problems.

I am exploring this possibility through FRISTEG, a free digital initiative I am developing in Sweden to help people understand their financial situation and prepare for contact with professional budget and debt advisers. It is still a prototype requiring further testing and expert validation, not a replacement for regulated financial or legal services.

The ambition is deliberately modest. No one should have to pay simply to begin understanding their own debts.

Yet the larger implications are anything but modest.

Imagine independent developers, consumer organisations, legal advisers and people with lived experience of debt working together to create open, accessible tools that help individuals understand the claims being made against them.

Imagine systems that explain the difference between the nominal value of a debt and the price at which such debts may trade, without misleading people into believing they have an automatic right to settle at that market price.

Imagine technology helping debtors identify inaccurate records, obtain documentation and understand the settlement options that may actually be available to them.

Such tools would not abolish the need for responsible lending, contractual obligations or legitimate debt collection. They might simply make the relationship between creditors and borrowers less dependent on unequal access to information.

And unlike many ambitious technology projects, much of this does not require enormous organisations or vast financial resources.

We now have tools that allow relatively small groups, and sometimes individual creators, to build useful software that would once have demanded entire development teams.

That opportunity deserves more attention than another application designed to make people spend money they do not have.

Thirty-eight years later, the real question is who has the power to negotiate

There is an old saying that if you owe the bank a thousand dollars, you have a problem; if you owe it a million, the bank has a problem. The precise wording varies, but the underlying observation concerns negotiating power.

Large debtors can sometimes force creditors to confront commercial reality because the consequences of failure are substantial enough to affect both sides. Governments negotiate restructurings. Corporations enter insolvency proceedings and reorganise their obligations. Financial institutions routinely write down assets when expected recoveries deteriorate.

Individuals can also negotiate settlements, obtain debt relief or use insolvency protections, depending on their circumstances and national laws. These options are real, although they can be difficult to understand, expensive to pursue or accompanied by serious consequences.

The issue is therefore not that ordinary people have no rights. It is that exercising those rights can require knowledge, confidence and resources that financially distressed people are particularly unlikely to possess.

When someone is struggling to pay rent, buy food or keep the electricity connected, becoming an expert in debt law and financial valuation is rarely their first priority.

And perhaps that is where our attention should shift.

I do not believe every unpaid debt should simply disappear. Borrowing and lending create obligations, and those obligations matter. Credit systems depend on reasonable expectations that agreements will be honoured, while careless debt cancellation policies can create costs for other borrowers and taxpayers.

But neither do I believe that a person's financial difficulties should automatically deprive them of the ability to question, understand or negotiate what is being demanded.

The distinction between financial responsibility and permanent financial punishment is one that modern society has still not properly resolved.

Bolivia's 1988 transaction did not solve the world's debt problems. Michael Sheen's initiative did not reform the British financial system. And no AI application is going to eliminate the complicated economic relationships that make modern credit possible.

But each offers a different perspective on something we have grown accustomed to accepting.

The value of a debt is not always the same as its face value. The market knows this. Banks know this. Investors know this. Governments know this.

Ordinary borrowers deserve to understand it too.

Perhaps the most useful development over the coming years will not be an algorithm that enables creditors to recover another fraction of a percentage point from distressed households. Perhaps it will be technology that gives those households a clearer understanding of their own position and helps them exercise the rights they already possess.

I began examining this subject through the story of Michael Sheen, then followed it into the unsettling business of forgotten mortgages and the remarkable history of Bolivia's debt buyback. What connects these stories is not a simple formula for making debts disappear. It is the uncomfortable discovery that the financial system can be remarkably flexible when dealing with professional participants, yet feel utterly inflexible to the people living under its consequences.

Thirty-eight years after Bolivia bought back almost half its commercial bank debt at 11 cents on the dollar, we are still asking who gets to negotiate, who gets to walk away and who must carry the burden.

Maybe the next important change will not come from someone wealthy enough to buy other people's debts.

Maybe it will come from ordinary people finally having the knowledge, the technology and the collective confidence to ask better questions about their own.


By Chris...